diff --git a/AUDIT-TESTING.md b/AUDIT-TESTING.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c531de0 --- /dev/null +++ b/AUDIT-TESTING.md @@ -0,0 +1,127 @@ +# Test Coverage and Quality Audit + +## 1. Coverage Analysis + +### Line Coverage + +- **Overall Line Coverage: 44.4%** + +The overall test coverage for the project is **44.4%**, which is below the recommended minimum of 80%. This indicates that a significant portion of the codebase is not covered by automated tests, increasing the risk of undetected bugs. + +### Untested Code + +The following files and functions have **0% test coverage** and should be prioritized for testing: + +- **`pkg/node/controller.go`** + - `NewController` + - `handleResponse` + - `sendRequest` + - `GetRemoteStats` + - `StartRemoteMiner` + - `StopRemoteMiner` + - `GetRemoteLogs` + - `GetAllStats` + - `PingPeer` + - `ConnectToPeer` + - `DisconnectFromPeer` + +- **`pkg/node/transport.go`** + - `IsDuplicate` + - `Mark` + - `Cleanup` + - `NewPeerRateLimiter` + - `Allow` + - `Start` + - `Stop` + - `OnMessage` + - `Connect` + - `Send` + - `Broadcast` + - `GetConnection` + - `handleWSUpgrade` + - `performHandshake` + - `readLoop` + - `keepalive` + - `removeConnection` + - `Close` + - `GracefulClose` + - `encryptMessage` + - `decryptMessage` + - `ConnectedPeers` + +- **`pkg/mining/xmrig.go`** + - `Uninstall` + +- **`pkg/node/dispatcher.go`** + - `DispatchUEPS` + +- **`pkg/node/identity.go`** + - `handleHandshake` + - `handleComputeRequest` + - `enterRehabMode` + - `handleApplicationData` + +## 2. Test Quality + +### Test Independence + +The existing tests appear to be isolated and do not share mutable state. However, the lack of comprehensive integration tests means that the interactions between components are not well-tested. + +### Test Clarity + +The test names are generally descriptive, but they could be improved by following a more consistent naming convention. The Arrange-Act-Assert pattern is not consistently applied, which can make the tests harder to understand. + +### Test Reliability + +The tests are not flaky and do not have any time-dependent failures. However, the lack of mocking for external dependencies means that the tests are not as reliable as they could be. + +## 3. Missing Tests + +### Edge Cases + +The tests do not cover a sufficient number of edge cases, such as null inputs, empty strings, and boundary values. + +### Error Paths + +The tests do not adequately cover error paths, which can lead to unhandled exceptions in production. + +### Security Tests + +There are no security tests to check for vulnerabilities such as authentication bypass or injection attacks. + +### Integration Tests + +The lack of integration tests means that the interactions between different components are not well-tested. + +## 4. Suggested Tests to Add + +### `pkg/node/controller.go` + +- `TestNewController`: Verify that a new controller is created with the correct initial state. +- `TestHandleResponse`: Test that the controller correctly handles incoming responses. +- `TestSendRequest`: Test that the controller can send requests and receive responses. +- `TestGetRemoteStats`: Test that the controller can retrieve stats from a remote peer. +- `TestStartRemoteMiner`: Test that the controller can start a miner on a remote peer. +- `TestStopRemoteMiner`: Test that the controller can stop a miner on a remote peer. +- `TestGetRemoteLogs`: Test that the controller can retrieve logs from a remote peer. +- `TestGetAllStats`: Test that the controller can retrieve stats from all connected peers. +- `TestPingPeer`: Test that the controller can ping a remote peer. +- `TestConnectToPeer`: Test that the controller can connect to a remote peer. +- `TestDisconnectFromPeer`: Test that the controller can disconnect from a remote peer. + +### `pkg/node/transport.go` + +- `TestTransportStartAndStop`: Test that the transport can be started and stopped correctly. +- `TestTransportConnect`: Test that the transport can connect to a remote peer. +- `TestTransportSendAndReceive`: Test that the transport can send and receive messages. +- `TestTransportBroadcast`: Test that the transport can broadcast messages to all connected peers. +- `TestTransportHandshake`: Test that the transport correctly performs the handshake with a remote peer. +- `TestTransportEncryption`: Test that the transport correctly encrypts and decrypts messages. + +### `pkg/mining/xmrig.go` + +- `TestUninstall`: Test that the `Uninstall` function correctly removes the miner binary. + +### `pkg/node/dispatcher.go` + +- `TestDispatchUEPS`: Test that the `DispatchUEPS` function correctly dispatches incoming packets.