core/php-api

Fork 0

discovery: scan php-api and create improvement issues #2

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-02-20 01:51:39 +00:00 by Clotho · 1 comment

Clotho commented

2026-02-20 01:51:39 +00:00

Member

Objective

Scan this module thoroughly and auto-create issues for everything that needs work.

Process

Read CLAUDE.md and TODO.md if they exist
Scan all source files - look for:
- Missing tests (files in src/ without corresponding test)
- TODO/FIXME/HACK comments in code
- Missing type hints or return types
- Empty methods or stub implementations
- Missing error handling
- Missing or outdated documentation
- Security concerns (SQL injection, XSS, mass assignment)
- Dead code or unused imports
- Missing migrations or seeders
- Config files that need environment variables
Check composer.json for:
- Outdated dependencies
- Missing dev dependencies (testing, analysis tools)
- Autoload paths correctness
Check tests/ for:
- Test coverage gaps
- Missing edge case tests
- Tests that are skipped or incomplete

Creating Issues

For EACH finding, create an issue on forge.lthn.ai:

curl -sf -X POST \
  -H "Authorization: token $FORGE_TOKEN_PROD" \
  -H "Content-Type: application/json" \
  "https://forge.lthn.ai/api/v1/repos/core/php-api/issues" \
  -d "{\"title\":\"type: description\",\"body\":\"details\",\"labels\":[48,47]}"

Issue types:

test: add tests for {Class/Method} — missing test coverage
fix: {description} — bugs or broken functionality
refactor: {description} — code quality improvements
security: {description} — security concerns (always label review)
docs: {description} — documentation gaps
chore: {description} — dependency updates, config fixes

Label ALL created issues with discovery. Label security/architectural concerns with review.

Also create ONE summary issue titled roadmap: php-api production readiness with a checklist of everything needed.

Branch

Work from dev branch. This is a READ-ONLY scan - create issues, do not modify code.

## Objective Scan this module thoroughly and auto-create issues for everything that needs work. ## Process 1. **Read CLAUDE.md and TODO.md** if they exist 2. **Scan all source files** - look for: - Missing tests (files in src/ without corresponding test) - TODO/FIXME/HACK comments in code - Missing type hints or return types - Empty methods or stub implementations - Missing error handling - Missing or outdated documentation - Security concerns (SQL injection, XSS, mass assignment) - Dead code or unused imports - Missing migrations or seeders - Config files that need environment variables 3. **Check composer.json** for: - Outdated dependencies - Missing dev dependencies (testing, analysis tools) - Autoload paths correctness 4. **Check tests/** for: - Test coverage gaps - Missing edge case tests - Tests that are skipped or incomplete ## Creating Issues For EACH finding, create an issue on forge.lthn.ai: ```bash curl -sf -X POST \ -H "Authorization: token $FORGE_TOKEN_PROD" \ -H "Content-Type: application/json" \ "https://forge.lthn.ai/api/v1/repos/core/php-api/issues" \ -d "{\"title\":\"type: description\",\"body\":\"details\",\"labels\":[48,47]}" ``` Issue types: - `test: add tests for {Class/Method}` — missing test coverage - `fix: {description}` — bugs or broken functionality - `refactor: {description}` — code quality improvements - `security: {description}` — security concerns (always label review) - `docs: {description}` — documentation gaps - `chore: {description}` — dependency updates, config fixes Label ALL created issues with `discovery`. Label security/architectural concerns with `review`. Also create ONE summary issue titled `roadmap: php-api production readiness` with a checklist of everything needed. ## Branch Work from dev branch. This is a READ-ONLY scan - create issues, do not modify code.

Clotho added the

clotho

discovery

labels 2026-02-20 01:51:39 +00:00

Snider added reference main

2026-02-20 01:57:52 +00:00

Clotho commented

2026-02-20 03:19:46 +00:00

Author

Member

Discovery Scan Complete ✅

Scanned: 107 PHP files (71 production files, 11 test files, 25 migrations/views)
Date: 2026-02-20
Agent: Clotho (agent201)

📋 Issues Created: 17 + 1 Roadmap

High Priority Issues (6)

#3 - test: add tests for IpRestrictionService (security-critical)
#4 - test: add tests for ApiSnippetService
#5 - test: add tests for WebhookSecretRotationService (security + review)
#7 - test: add tests for TrackApiUsage middleware
#8 - test: add tests for PublicApiCors middleware (security + review)
#12 - test: add tests for console commands (cleanup, alerts)

Medium Priority Issues (8)

#6 - test: add tests for OpenAPI documentation extensions
#9 - test: add tests for WebhookPayloadTemplate model
#10 - test: add tests for API resource transformers
#11 - test: add tests for WebhookTemplateController
#13 - refactor: extract workspace validation to middleware
#14 - refactor: deduplicate webhook lookup pattern
#15 - fix: implement readResourceViaArtisan in McpApiController (stub found)
#16 - refactor: wrap proc_open in dedicated service class

Low Priority Issues (3)

#17 - docs: add comprehensive @param and @return annotations
#18 - refactor: extract magic numbers to named constants
#19 - chore: audit and update composer.json (needs review)

Roadmap

#20 - roadmap: php-api production readiness (master tracking issue)

🔍 Scan Findings Summary

✅ Security Analysis - EXCELLENT

No critical vulnerabilities found! The codebase demonstrates mature security practices:

✅ SQL Injection: All database queries use Eloquent ORM with parameter binding
✅ XSS Protection: Proper output escaping (htmlspecialchars with ENT_QUOTES | ENT_HTML5)
✅ Mass Assignment: All models properly define $fillable arrays
✅ Secure Randomness: Uses Str::random() / random_bytes() (no rand() or mt_rand())
✅ API Key Hashing: Bcrypt hashing with legacy SHA-256 detection
✅ Webhook Signatures: HMAC-SHA256 with timing-safe comparison
✅ IP Validation: Proper CIDR/IPv6 handling with filter_var()
✅ Input Validation: Comprehensive request validation throughout

📊 Test Coverage Analysis

Current State: 11 test files covering major features

✅ API Key Security (hashing, rotation, IP whitelisting)
✅ Webhook Delivery (signatures, retries, exponential backoff)
✅ Rate Limiting (tier-based, headers, quotas, burst)
✅ Scope Enforcement (wildcards, inheritance)
✅ OpenAPI Documentation (schema generation)

Gaps Identified: 10 missing test files

Services: IpRestrictionService, ApiSnippetService, WebhookSecretRotationService
Middleware: TrackApiUsage, PublicApiCors
Controllers: WebhookTemplateController
Models: WebhookPayloadTemplate
Resources: All resource transformers
Console Commands: 3 commands without tests
Extensions: OpenAPI extensions untested

🔧 Code Quality Findings

Duplicated Code:

WebhookSecretController: 8x workspace validation pattern (lines 28-32, 66-70, etc.)
WebhookSecretController: 7x webhook lookup pattern (lines 34-40, 72-78, etc.)

Stub Implementation:

McpApiController:499 - readResourceViaArtisan() returns placeholder response

Architecture:

McpApiController uses proc_open() directly (should be wrapped in service)

Magic Numbers:

WebhookDelivery:98 - 10000 (response body limit)
WebhookService:119 - 100 (batch size)
McpApiController - 600 (cache TTL)

📚 Documentation Gaps

Missing detailed @param/@return annotations on complex methods
Array shape documentation needed for config arrays
Missing usage examples for complex services

📦 Infrastructure

composer.json lacks explicit dev dependencies (may be inherited from parent)
@dev stability for host-uk/core (review needed)

🎯 Recommendations

Immediate Actions (Week 1)

Prioritize security-related tests: #3 (IP restrictions), #8 (CORS), #5 (secret rotation)
Fix stub implementation: #15 (MCP resource reading)
Add critical middleware tests: #7 (usage tracking)

Follow-up (Weeks 2-4)

Complete remaining test coverage (#4, #6, #9, #10, #11, #12)
Refactor duplicated code (#13, #14)
Polish documentation (#17, #18)
Review composer.json strategy (#19)

Production Readiness

After completing high-priority issues (#3-#8, #12), this package will have comprehensive test coverage for all security-critical paths. The codebase is already well-architected with excellent security practices.

📈 Overall Assessment

Grade: A- (Production-Ready with Minor Gaps)

Strengths:

✅ Excellent security implementation
✅ No critical bugs or vulnerabilities
✅ PSR-12 compliant with strict_types
✅ Event-driven architecture
✅ Comprehensive existing test coverage for core features
✅ Well-documented with CLAUDE.md and TODO.md

Areas for Improvement:

⚠️ Test coverage gaps (10 missing test files)
⚠️ Code duplication in WebhookSecretController
⚠️ One stub implementation (non-critical feature)
⚠️ Documentation could be more detailed

Verdict: This is a mature, well-built API package that requires test coverage completion and minor refactoring, not architectural changes. No blockers for production use.

All 18 issues have been created and labeled with discovery. See #20 (roadmap) for implementation plan and prioritization.

Full scan details available in the Explore agent output (agent a763494).

## Discovery Scan Complete ✅ **Scanned**: 107 PHP files (71 production files, 11 test files, 25 migrations/views) **Date**: 2026-02-20 **Agent**: Clotho (agent201) --- ## 📋 Issues Created: 17 + 1 Roadmap ### High Priority Issues (6) 1. **#3** - test: add tests for IpRestrictionService (security-critical) 2. **#4** - test: add tests for ApiSnippetService 3. **#5** - test: add tests for WebhookSecretRotationService (security + review) 4. **#7** - test: add tests for TrackApiUsage middleware 5. **#8** - test: add tests for PublicApiCors middleware (security + review) 6. **#12** - test: add tests for console commands (cleanup, alerts) ### Medium Priority Issues (8) 7. **#6** - test: add tests for OpenAPI documentation extensions 8. **#9** - test: add tests for WebhookPayloadTemplate model 9. **#10** - test: add tests for API resource transformers 10. **#11** - test: add tests for WebhookTemplateController 11. **#13** - refactor: extract workspace validation to middleware 12. **#14** - refactor: deduplicate webhook lookup pattern 13. **#15** - fix: implement readResourceViaArtisan in McpApiController (stub found) 14. **#16** - refactor: wrap proc_open in dedicated service class ### Low Priority Issues (3) 15. **#17** - docs: add comprehensive @param and @return annotations 16. **#18** - refactor: extract magic numbers to named constants 17. **#19** - chore: audit and update composer.json (needs review) ### Roadmap 18. **#20** - roadmap: php-api production readiness (master tracking issue) --- ## 🔍 Scan Findings Summary ### ✅ Security Analysis - EXCELLENT **No critical vulnerabilities found!** The codebase demonstrates mature security practices: - ✅ **SQL Injection**: All database queries use Eloquent ORM with parameter binding - ✅ **XSS Protection**: Proper output escaping (htmlspecialchars with ENT_QUOTES | ENT_HTML5) - ✅ **Mass Assignment**: All models properly define $fillable arrays - ✅ **Secure Randomness**: Uses Str::random() / random_bytes() (no rand() or mt_rand()) - ✅ **API Key Hashing**: Bcrypt hashing with legacy SHA-256 detection - ✅ **Webhook Signatures**: HMAC-SHA256 with timing-safe comparison - ✅ **IP Validation**: Proper CIDR/IPv6 handling with filter_var() - ✅ **Input Validation**: Comprehensive request validation throughout ### 📊 Test Coverage Analysis **Current State**: 11 test files covering major features - ✅ API Key Security (hashing, rotation, IP whitelisting) - ✅ Webhook Delivery (signatures, retries, exponential backoff) - ✅ Rate Limiting (tier-based, headers, quotas, burst) - ✅ Scope Enforcement (wildcards, inheritance) - ✅ OpenAPI Documentation (schema generation) **Gaps Identified**: 10 missing test files - Services: IpRestrictionService, ApiSnippetService, WebhookSecretRotationService - Middleware: TrackApiUsage, PublicApiCors - Controllers: WebhookTemplateController - Models: WebhookPayloadTemplate - Resources: All resource transformers - Console Commands: 3 commands without tests - Extensions: OpenAPI extensions untested ### 🔧 Code Quality Findings **Duplicated Code**: - WebhookSecretController: 8x workspace validation pattern (lines 28-32, 66-70, etc.) - WebhookSecretController: 7x webhook lookup pattern (lines 34-40, 72-78, etc.) **Stub Implementation**: - McpApiController:499 - `readResourceViaArtisan()` returns placeholder response **Architecture**: - McpApiController uses `proc_open()` directly (should be wrapped in service) **Magic Numbers**: - WebhookDelivery:98 - `10000` (response body limit) - WebhookService:119 - `100` (batch size) - McpApiController - `600` (cache TTL) ### 📚 Documentation Gaps - Missing detailed @param/@return annotations on complex methods - Array shape documentation needed for config arrays - Missing usage examples for complex services ### 📦 Infrastructure - composer.json lacks explicit dev dependencies (may be inherited from parent) - @dev stability for host-uk/core (review needed) --- ## 🎯 Recommendations ### Immediate Actions (Week 1) 1. Prioritize security-related tests: #3 (IP restrictions), #8 (CORS), #5 (secret rotation) 2. Fix stub implementation: #15 (MCP resource reading) 3. Add critical middleware tests: #7 (usage tracking) ### Follow-up (Weeks 2-4) 4. Complete remaining test coverage (#4, #6, #9, #10, #11, #12) 5. Refactor duplicated code (#13, #14) 6. Polish documentation (#17, #18) 7. Review composer.json strategy (#19) ### Production Readiness After completing high-priority issues (#3-#8, #12), this package will have comprehensive test coverage for all security-critical paths. The codebase is already well-architected with excellent security practices. --- ## 📈 Overall Assessment **Grade: A- (Production-Ready with Minor Gaps)** **Strengths**: - ✅ Excellent security implementation - ✅ No critical bugs or vulnerabilities - ✅ PSR-12 compliant with strict_types - ✅ Event-driven architecture - ✅ Comprehensive existing test coverage for core features - ✅ Well-documented with CLAUDE.md and TODO.md **Areas for Improvement**: - ⚠️ Test coverage gaps (10 missing test files) - ⚠️ Code duplication in WebhookSecretController - ⚠️ One stub implementation (non-critical feature) - ⚠️ Documentation could be more detailed **Verdict**: This is a **mature, well-built API package** that requires test coverage completion and minor refactoring, not architectural changes. No blockers for production use. --- **All 18 issues have been created and labeled with `discovery`.** See #20 (roadmap) for implementation plan and prioritization. *Full scan details available in the Explore agent output (agent a763494).*